What if- Considering Local History
Updated: 4 days ago
A review of the documentary film- about Sullivan's March of 1779- Brian Keeler
What if history had been different - or better yet, what if our current take on history would be more humane. These are two of the takeaways after viewing a film about General John Sullivan's campaign that passed through my hometown in the summer of 1779. In fact, this expedition of several thousand soldiers got waylaid there at the mouth of the Wyalusing Creek for three days. A period of intense rains apparently slogged them into a temporary standstill. I have paddled the river in flood stage and one year our small group even paddled up the Wyalusing creek at the end of our trip. So I have some experience with this scenario.
The "What if" game or serious contemplation of history is something that easily comes up when regarding events of the past. We are tempted to wonder about other scenarios- if only this or that had been done instead of what actually occurred. Time travel aside, we cannot influence the past- and our lives and understanding of the present are enriched by trying to understand and appreciate the past.

Above- A painting by the author depicting a view of the Susquehanna valley just upstream from Wyalusing. Sullivan's army would have passed near this vantage point in 1779.
Having grown up along the Susquehanna- where the main historical event was this military campaign during the Revolutionary War- it was very rewarding to have so many of the facts about this mission portrayed and laid out in this documentary. (The film was screened in the auditorium of the high school that I attended. But you wouldn't know it - as the current remodeled version of this theater is nothing like it was when I went to school there. The auditorium has undergone an amazing renovation and it's impressive in every way.)
This documentary film was presented by the Wyalusing Valley Museum. The 250th anniversary of the United States was the motivating factor for the local filmmaker Steven Berwick to produce this historical update. Berwick is a paramedic by day and he has this serious hobby as an historian and producer of films. Viewing the film in the company of many locals was a treat as it was a community event about a subject important to the town, the county and region of New York and Pennsylvania. Its connection to the Revolutionary War makes it related to our national heritage and even international relations. The French revolution was a consequence, and that too had relevance in Bradford County with a refuge for Maria Antionette built just upstream from Wyalusing.
Clearly, extensive research had been done for the film and it was indeed engaging to learn about so many of the facts, details and geographical aspects. Berwick does employ AI film techniques that we've become used to in recent months. On YouTube, there are amazing creations of ancient history of Rome and elsewhere that are impressive- if not somewhat easily recognizable. It seems that just by suggesting a scenario and intent, the producer can have AI create episodes with settings and facsimiles of real actors all portraying the intended events. These are also referred to as CGI, for computer generated images. The imagery and pseudo actors (or cyber actors) do help to convey and illustrate the story- but there are drawbacks. For example, every time the film showed the rafts or boats on the river- they were always depicted coming downstream. We know that the mission was going north and up the river. Berwick did use other graphics, historical illustrations, maps, paintings and he relied on the diaries of the soldiers to supply candid reportage of the time. He even included a pastel of mine showing the early settlement of Friedenshutten, which preceded the Sullivan campaign.
The central charge of the Sullivan campaign through the Susquehanna's northern section and into the Finger Lakes was from George Washington. This mandate was to destroy the Native American villages, eliminate the populations and burn their crops. There are numerous roadside plaques in the Finger Lakes recording these scorched earth assaults. For example, in Hector, NY on Seneca Lake there is a commemorative plaque about the burning of entire peach orchards. This policy and Sullivan's mandate was accomplished to horrible effect - ending in a march of the displaced in the coldest winter on record up to that time. The fatalities in battle were made incidental to the loss of life and great suffering in this exodus. It was a human tragedy of great proportions.

Above- a plein air painting by the author of the Susquehanna Valley just north of Wyalusing. The views like this one (from a private property) are much like they were in 1779 at the time of Sullivan's March through Bradford County, PA.
At the end of the film, the director asks the question "was the campaign a success?" The answer depends on who you ask. Certainly the American Indians did not regard it with any kind of high regard. The point that was missing in the presentation was that this was a hostile and cruel act during a war, but not restricted to combatants. In the other parts of the Revolutionary War and in other wars in general- ostensibly the belligerents are attacking other militaries. But we know this is not the case in most wars. Take Ukraine for example, where civilians are being targeted and killed in mass on a daily basis. Here in Bradford County and New York the aggression was directed toward an entire people. Hence, it deserves the term genocide.
So, as important as history and local history are to us- I am wondering about the general attitude and manner of the presentation. Berwick's approach is certainly not slanted. Still the way this aspect of our history has been recorded and presented on roadside plaques would lead one to believe that Sullivan's March was perhaps a noble effort. We understand George Washington's motivation and how he was regarded after a campaign in the 1750's near Pittsburgh during the French and Indian War. This is known for its arrogant British General Braddock who led the ill-fated assault. It ended in disaster with the British being completely routed. Washington himself barely escaped with his life. This episode was covered in detail in a book that I recently read titled, First Principles. So we can understand Washington's motivation not to repeat that debacle. And to give Washington his due, there were two incidents of conflict between settlers and Native Americans that precipitated the justification for military intervention. One was at Cherry Valley, near Cooperstown, NY and the other in the Wyoming Valley near Wilkes- Barre, PA.
Still, the incursion into Bradford County and the Finger Lakes seems like overreach and misguided hostility. After all, we were at war with the British and trying to throw off the shackles of monarchy. One could surmise that fighting small bands of ill-equipped Indians and burning villages with families was an easier route to military success than confronting British soldiers.
The "What if's" come in here. For example, what if diplomacy had been considered instead of a massive military campaign. Perhaps a reasoned arrangement and truce could have been negotiated. What if the men carrying out this destruction had considered the consequences of their acts. Yes, those were different times and it may be unfair to retrofit modern morality into an 18th century conflict. And before we become too sanctimonious with our current morality- we don't have to look far to see many examples of horrific cruelty done in the name of national security. Just consider the ICE efforts of deportations, cold-blooded murder and imprisonments

Above- This painting by the author of the Susquehanna valley depicts the area of French Azilum a few miles north of Wyalusing. Sullivan's troops would have passed over this area on their march north.
To put this in context, here is a consideration. The method of this removal of an entire population here could be compared to going to Britain and deporting all of a section of that island to a frozen wasteland. This, of course, would never have been entertained. Hence, the Sullivan and Washington attitudes can be viewed as racist-based hostilities.
Many of the practical aspects of logistics of this campaign were brought out in Berwick's film. How would several thousand men be camped out at the mouth of the Wyalusing Creek along with countless animals and supply trains. Seems like they would have had to carry out a massive ground clearing just to prepare. The flora and fauna are also mentioned in the film with interest. For example, it was recorded that there were sycamore trees that were a massive 25 feet in circumference. It was of note that Sullivan's soldiers were ordered not to fire at any of the wild animals so as not to draw undue attention. Yet, they had no qualms about firing cannons at the Standing Stone and at other times.
Other aspects of our history were mentioned that occurred a few years after or before Sullivan's march. The film noted the Friendenshutten village, as mentioned earlier, and also the Battle of Lime Hill just outside of Wyalusing. This battle of 1782 was the last aspect of the Revolutionary War in Bradford County. I illustrated this episode several years ago. It was commissioned by local history buff Mike Kilmer and donated to the Wyalusing Valley Museum where it now hangs. And French Azilum was mentioned in the talk too, although this occurred 1n the 1790's - and it was related to the French Revolution. Again, I reflected on how the battle was portrayed with the CGI as compared to my own interpretation. The CGI showed the battle in an open area. I think my own was more accurate by depicting the seesaw battle in a forested area. Also the CGI imagery was probably created in minutes- mine involved an extended period of development involving a series of drawings and a conceptual and creative effort. Hmm, this AI history stuff seems too easy- like essays kids are writing these days with AI doing all the effort- cheating perhaps or at least undermining the joy and rewards of creating.

above- The author's painting of the Battle of Lime Hill. Now in the Wyalusng Valley Museum,.
Having painted this area of the Susquehanna for my entire career, it was indeed enriching and informative to learn about so many details and facts of our history through Berwick's film. The precarious ridge side trails that the soldiers traversed on the mountain opposite Towanda was one such detail.
All in all the film provided an enjoyable and informative evening. It allowed us all to reconsider our history, topography, and cultural backgrounds. The beauty of the vistas over the river were remarked upon in the diaries of those soldiers and we still find these panoramas inspiring. It was evocative of my childhood summers along the Wyalusing Creek and the Susquehanna, as the mouth of the creek is where this massive group of soldiers camped.
Since the incursion of AI has been mentioned throught this reflection, it is worth noting in conclusion that these data centers are being foisted on us to create the cheating culture- and they could possibly fill in these beautiful valleys of the Susquehanna and obliterate history. A similar industrial intrusion happened near Wyalusing with a massive LNG plant nearly overwhelming and obliterating an historical site near Browntown, PA- just downriver from Wyalusing. Beautiful land was bulldozed without a peep from the history buffs or any of the museums.

Above the author's painting of the Susquehanna at Sugar Run, PA. Views like this are very similar to the time of Sullivan's March. The brush on the left turning rust-colored in the November light, is kudzu, an invasive that is pervasive now - but was not there in 1779. This painting is an 18" x 48" oil on linen panel. But playing the "What if game," are these views certain to be there for future generations if LNG plants or data centers are to be allowed.
View a video recap- of this work- after the first plein air session- https://youtu.be/1GYZfblWcgg?si=CZbFFUeXszzitIQk




Comments